What's Next for Scott Arniel?
After his recent... episode... what is next for Scott Arniel?
His reaction was, in a word, embarrassing. Embarrassing for both him and the Blue Jackets organization. I understand being frustrated. Taking it out on a group of reporters when you're in a hole you've dug for yourself is unnecessary.
Beyond that, what does this do to his voice in the room? Does this make Rick Nash feel like the coach has his back? Or does he think he's being coached by someone who can't handle the pressure of the NHL?
If this were Toronto or Philadelphia or New York, Arniel's record, excuses, and complete lack of knowledge of his team wouldn't last another minute.
Can Scott Howson really continue to stand behind Arniel? Do you think Jeff Carter is happy with the idea that he's expected to listen to this guy?
Arniel's team dug a hole for itself well before Christmas. In Columbus, we'll take the first chance to find any "positive signs," no matter how insignificant. Continuing to work hard but analyze his team in an honest manner would have gone a long way. Having such a combative response when someone asks a simple question is not the attitude I'd want to see. At this point, the organization is still expecting him to bring along the next generation of young players.
His credibility among the NHL and the Blue Jackets fan base is next to zero. Whether Howson or Blue Jackets President Mike Priest still believe in him, what can his credibility be throughout the rest of the organization?
Maybe Howson and Priest believe admitting that Arniel isn't right for the job is admitting too much failure on their behalf.
And maybe that's the problem.
38 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Case in point: When I saw this headline my heart jumped as I thought Arniel had been fired. In the words of Bunson Honeydew, “the effect was sadly temporary.”
I was suckered by the headline, too!
Just once I'd like someone to call me "Sir," without adding, "You're making a scene."
Andy, I think you’ve touched on the fundamental flaw at the end, here. Scott Howson is walking a tightrope, between convincing ownership that he’s made the right decision in hiring Arniel, whereas Arniel is quickly proving that not to be the case. If Howson admits it to ownership, it undermines his entire job performance to this point.
Writer for The Cannon - A Columbus Blue Jackets blog
Follow me on Twitter
"I will say anything to be funny, often in the most horrible situations, which is one reason [a] good [woman] so far [has] been very sorry on occasion to have married me." --Kurt Vonnegut, Jr.
So where does that leave us fans, Dan?
My fear is now that the 4 days off is over, Howson et al will be content to wait until the off season to do anything.
And if that is the case, how many players will be dumped as this train wreck grinds to a halt in April?
Just once I'd like someone to call me "Sir," without adding, "You're making a scene."
It's a chicken/egg conundrum
Is it the coach? Or is it the players?
Either way, this thing needs to be built RIGHT.
If it’s the coach, then Howson needs to act now, and needs to tell us WHY. And needs to tell us what kind of coach he thinks can get this roster to play to its fullest potential. Then, the next coaching search needs to be more than four or five candidates like it was last time. Leave no stone unturned.
If it’s the players, the Howson needs to be straight with EVERYONE that the plan is to purge the room of what’s wrong—and we need to hear SPECIFICS—and build from the ground up with the RIGHT kind of players. I don’t want to start over again, but if Howson can lay out a reasoned plan for why Arniel needs to stay I could at least digest it and see if it makes sense. I think there’s talent here, but something is clearly holding it back. We’ve had two or three coaches with a large chunk of this core, and it hasn’t worked. So, I could actually envision a scenario where Howson could convince everyone above him to go along for a full rebuild.
Writer for The Cannon - A Columbus Blue Jackets blog
Follow me on Twitter
"I will say anything to be funny, often in the most horrible situations, which is one reason [a] good [woman] so far [has] been very sorry on occasion to have married me." --Kurt Vonnegut, Jr.
We had one
Our roster quit on him.
Writer for The Cannon - A Columbus Blue Jackets blog
Follow me on Twitter
"I will say anything to be funny, often in the most horrible situations, which is one reason [a] good [woman] so far [has] been very sorry on occasion to have married me." --Kurt Vonnegut, Jr.
Let me reword. Lets get a proven coach that doesnt have a history of over pushing/ having player quit on him. Someone who is good at working with young players and has coaches in the NHL before.
Plus our roster quit on Hitch after they bought into his system and made the playoffs. Ill take that for now.
Very clear, concise analysis, Andy, thanks.
"If less is more, think how much more MORE is!"
by pete goegan on Jan 4, 2012 11:36 AM EST via mobile reply actions
Hopefully whats next for Arniel is a lot more family time back home.
I think hit the nail on the head above. My guess is Howson basically knows that if he fires Arniel, he himself has reached his end. But as long as he keeps insisting Arniel was the right choice, he is safe it seems. This is another time where having non hockey minds up higher in the organization really hurts.
I believe the team has quit on Arniel. He’s been exposed to the public now, but the team has been dealing with this since last season. You can see it in the lack of energy and passion among the leaders, and the way this team blows leads. Even Voracek’s tweet standing up for Brassard was revealing. Arniel is in way over his head. For his sake, the team and the fans, terminate him immediately.
by ibleedunionblue on Jan 4, 2012 12:05 PM EST reply actions
So, this would be, what, three coaches...
…that this core has quit on? At what point do we point our fingers in another direction?
Writer for The Cannon - A Columbus Blue Jackets blog
Follow me on Twitter
"I will say anything to be funny, often in the most horrible situations, which is one reason [a] good [woman] so far [has] been very sorry on occasion to have married me." --Kurt Vonnegut, Jr.
Im not so sure the team has quit on the coach as much as they dont understand what the hell he is talking about. The dude changes the lines every 2 minutes and every change seems to be questionable at best.
Im sure it doesnt help if your Nash or Carter and you see Derek Dorsett get more minutes than you either.
Dan, your point about it being three coaches that this core has quit on seems to be what frustrates the fans as much as anything. I think the problems are deeper than the coach, the GM, and the players. More changes need to be made to turn this organization around.
by cbjfan14 on Jan 4, 2012 2:43 PM EST up reply actions 1 recs
But this current core is different than the one seen last year. This one is more suited to play the higher-offense, up-tempo style that at least I expected this year. And instead we’re looking at a more offensively-talented team trying to play a defense-ish game with 2.37 goals per game instead of last years 2.56.
That dip in production (especially with a more offensively-oriented team), the strange ice-time values from game to game, the weird line combos, and the (at least to me) confusing choices in healthy scratches from game to game would seem to indicate a coaching problem.
(Which doesn’t exclude there being other problems, but just looking at Arniel’s issues: he doesn’t seem to be helping)
CCT, CBJ, SU, NYM, Bills Fan. It can be depressing.
Sometimes I tweet things
The only thing I can offer in terms of why I think Arniel ices the lineups he does is that this team gets whipped defensively SO often that he’s more likely to put his checking line out there every chance he can get.
It’s also important to note that the top five forwards in total ATOI this season are STILL Carter, Nash, Prospal, Umberger, and Vermette. it’s not like Dorse is far and away stealing all the minutes.
Writer for The Cannon - A Columbus Blue Jackets blog
Follow me on Twitter
"I will say anything to be funny, often in the most horrible situations, which is one reason [a] good [woman] so far [has] been very sorry on occasion to have married me." --Kurt Vonnegut, Jr.
I think a great deal of this could be solved through new goaltending and new coaching. It’s obviously a very subjective observation, but the team looked better when Sanford was in net. They didn’t have a visible tension/letdown leading up to or prior to a soft Mason goal. His ridiculously poor save % isn’t much to stand in front of.
I also just can’t get past the Brassard/Johansen scratches/benchings, especially when the team is seemingly always falling behind. Why would you keep any offensive talent off the ice? I’m especially confused when Johansen doesn’t show up on ice for many third periods. I know it’s a developmental thing (playing better defensively, etc), but at some point winning and scoring will have to matter. Or if you’re that far behind anyway, why not let the youth into games and let offensive creativity/talent drive the play?
CCT, CBJ, SU, NYM, Bills Fan. It can be depressing.
Sometimes I tweet things
By waiting so long through the failings of Arniel, Scott Howson has effectively tied his fate to his coaching choice. If he would have distanced himself earlier, it’s likely that we could have forgiven some of Howson’s managing sins – Arniel was a highly touted coach after all. But instead he chose to stay the course and has seriously hurt any positivity that his GM tenure once had. Poor contracts and sticking with Mason were balanced by a playoff appearance and good trading.
But now his inexplicable coaching choice (somehow claiming it wasn’t/isn’t the problem) has pushed him over the edge. I sincerely hope Howson doesn’t blow up the actually-good core of this team as he continues to employ Scott Arniel. It would be a shame if Howson’s perception of coaching (and thus his new need-to-trade as a solution to failure) managed to undo all the roster-building he has done.
CCT, CBJ, SU, NYM, Bills Fan. It can be depressing.
Sometimes I tweet things
Great point
Throughout the season, I’ve been reluctant to call for heads to roll simply because of the instability it brings to an organization. The epic collapse against the Preds in early December was the turning point for me with regards to Arniel. He needs to get canned.
At that point I thought Howson had done a reasonable job with building the roster via good trades. Sticking with Arniel through another month of club league quality hockey while insisting that “coaching is not the problem” is ridiculous. I’m firmly of the opinion (and largely thanks to your persuasive arguments) that Howson is as much a problem as Arniel and the players. Holding onto Arniel exposes Howson’s shortcomings.
Unfortunately I think Arniel is more likely to quit (or be institutionalized) before he is fired. If Arniel is fired but Howson keeps his job, I expect the on ice product to remain the same. Consider it a sign that McConnell’s view is obscured by wool.
Quitting on another coach
How many coaches will we let the team quit on? I don’t think Arniel is the solution, however I like that they are making the players have to work with him. Everybody wanted an up tempo system, when they quit on Hitch. Here it is, and it’s the same attitude.
I like that Howson told Carter he was part of the solution, as we cannot have players dictate where they will play. Jeff you are here for the term of your contract, start playing.
The last guys off the ice each practice….Johan, Moore, Vinnie…where’s Nash, Carter, RJ? Probably at he bank.
by Dutchman1350 on Jan 4, 2012 1:14 PM EST reply actions
The last guys off the ice each practice….Johan, Moore, Vinnie…where’s Nash, Carter, RJ? Probably at he bank.
>
Its funny you mention that, because i decided to go early to see warmups against Washington and went to the opposing side as I always do, and the last four players off the ice for the Capitals were Ovechkin, Backstrom, Carlson, and Semin as they were practicing one timers and wrist shots from the circles.
Then i looked to the other side and the last four off the ice were Johansen, Boll, Prospal, and either Sanford or Moore.
Combine this with the fact that Portzline has repeatedly reported that the Jackets practices are about 40% as intense as pretty much every other team that comes to town.
But, is that on the players, or on the coaches? Are the coaches letting them slide? Or do the players just not care? I mean, you can only bag skate guys so many times before they basically tune you out altogether. Todd Richards knows that all too well from his tenure in Minnesota.
Writer for The Cannon - A Columbus Blue Jackets blog
Follow me on Twitter
"I will say anything to be funny, often in the most horrible situations, which is one reason [a] good [woman] so far [has] been very sorry on occasion to have married me." --Kurt Vonnegut, Jr.
If I was captain, and practice was cancelled, I would make sure practice happened anyway. Maybe the coach gives them chances, but they continuously fail.
by Dutchman1350 on Jan 4, 2012 3:01 PM EST up reply actions
The way Portzline makes it sound is that it’s not a difference between bag skating and normal practice, it’s that the CBJ practices are played about about half speed of what the teams coming in do with a lot more stopping.
40% when they have them. I get tired of reading that the CBJ have canceled practice.
This team doesn’t win enough to cancel practice…
Just once I'd like someone to call me "Sir," without adding, "You're making a scene."
Time to Move On
Somebody in authority in the CBJ organization has got to realize that it’s time to move on. Frankly, I’d suggest that Mr. Priest fired Howson and Arniel, bring in a GM (Patrick? Does he want it?), and let the GM hire his coach. Do this before the end of January (today would be nice). Then let this new team start moving those players it can/needs to and start rebuilding the on-ice product (as these new management types are fond of calling it) into something people will pay to see. I don’t see any other way to achieve some sort of different results from what we have seen the past three seasons. Since this season is totally trashed, get a new team in place and use the remainder of the season to figure out what you do for next year. But use a different GM/Coach team. The one we have is broken.
It wouldnt bother me if Howson made it to the end of the season. Its much harder to change a GM at this point in the season with trade deadline coming up and Howson really hasnt been bad at all with his trades aside from the Chimera trade.
After the season, hopefully Arniel, Howson, and Priest are all gone so that we can start over.
I apologize in advance because this is going to be a long, and possibly a well thought out, rant.
Seriously? Scott Arniel still has his job? I don’t think any one of us who’ve read this blog would continue to have our employers retain us if we produced at the same level that Scott Arniel has. Clearly coaches who have come close to the same ineptness as Arniel this season have already been handed their pink slips, as most should have. Our record is the WORST in the league and yet Arniel still has the keys to the car. When he first came in, I really enjoyed who he had sitting up in the press box during games. It sent a message that the players need to and would be held to a higher standard. Someone needs to show him he hasn’t even come close to embodying those said standards himself.
Speaking of sending messages, what does this lack of action send to the rapidly deteriorating fan base we have left and to the others on the fringe? Arniel’s record this past calendar year is cancerous to attendance. The CBJ brass has been very blessed with an extraordinarily patient and committed fan base that comes from such a small market, but cracks are showing. Attendance hasn’t exactly been stellar this year, and one of the main reasons it has been up lately, in my opinion, is largely due to what equates to morbid curiosity. We know we shouldn’t watch that train smash into that car that broke down on the tracks, but we watch anyways. Eventually people will grow tired of that novelty, and attendance rates will be in the league cellar, just like our record.
I know it’s widely believed that Hitch lost the room towards the end of his tenure, but I’ll never understand why. Because Filatov and other punks felt they weren’t being rewarded even after they had “won the game” a time or two for their teams? Last time I checked, Hitch found success everywhere he coached and won that shiny silver trophy people tend to make a big deal out of. Oh yeah, he also got us to our lone playoff appearance on a team that didn’t exactly scream talent. Why the brass ever caved into the players not buying in to a stabilizing force and proven winner’s message is beyond me.
Them not buying into Arniel’s message doesn’t surprise me at all. How can they buy into anything when they don’t know what the hell it is? The first six weeks of the season, our defense looked utterly lost. I understand many were new to the team and had new partners, but many are veteran players simply looked baffled by the game they make a living off of and have for many years. That, to me, seems to be indicative of a coach not communicating and explaining his system well. The fact it took six weeks to reach a level even resembling respectability at our blue line is even more damning. Add in how other rosters with major overhauls found their stride in the first week is just more compelling evidence he’s more than worn out his welcome here.
Another aspect of Arniel’s coaching that has boggled my mind is his constant shuffling of the lines, game-to-game, shift-to-shift. There seems to be no rhyme or reason to it. I could excuse this if it yielded any results, but it clearly has not. It’s like he just throw’s s*** against a wall and hope it sticks. Even when it appears to be sticking, he takes it all off the wall, shuffles it around some more and throws it yet again. How can you expect any chemistry or cohesion to develop when you throw your lines into a blender every other shift and hope something good comes out of it.
His character has been called into question recently as well. I understood the man is frustrated. I’ve had many failures in life, but I’ve never had them witnessed and scrutinized in such a public manner. I know it must be brutal, but when you blow up and then pout because a member of the media who is just doing their job and doing it well, it speaks volumes about you. So you can try to unload on a female member of the press, but at times you’ve looked downright docile when you know damn well the refs made a terrible call? When other coaches protest garbage calls, the refs seem to at least pretend to give them a listen. When Arniel would call them out, they’d swat him away like he was an annoying gnat, like he was a rookie to the game, and Arniel would just capitulate and pout like he did when the press presented him some cold, hard facts. For someone that has been around the game for 25 years or more, he doesn’t seem to command much respect from the refs and now the players under him. If the press is being too hard for you here, try coaching … anywhere else. You’d find the heat in that kitchen isn’t any cooler there.
Another frustrating aspect of all of this is no coach has ever had the blank check to get skilled players like Arniel has. He appeared to have the best team on paper we’ve ever had at the beginning of the season, and what has he done with it? Injuries, not his fault. Veteran regressing is quality of play, probably not all of his fault. Everything else… much of it falls on his shoulders. He is the head coach after all.
Surely the players, GM and team president share much of of the blame as well, but he’s at fault on more than enough to be let go of. Honestly, it should have happened weeks ago. Maybe it’s Howson trying to save his bacon. If that’s all it is, why isn’t Priest or McConnell going, “Scott (Howson), we’ve seen more than enough. It’ past time to let him go. He doesn’t live up to our or our fans’ expectations and standards”? Give someone the interim tag and let the chips fall where they may for this season. Fail for Nail. I don’t care. At least show what few fans you have left that you care and know enough to understand this isn’t acceptable.
I’m all for stability, so long as it couples with success. Nothing Arniel has shown me leads me to believe he is that guy. I hate having a coaching carousal, but this guy is in way over his head. Columbus is one hell of a sports town, and we deserve one hell of a coach and one hell of a team to compliment our fandom and our hard earned money spent, which feels simply wasted watching this perpetual train wreck.
Great post, I completely agree.
Editor for The Cannon -- A Columbus Blue Jackets Blog
Follow me on Twitter - @andynewman

by 




















