This is simple. If you had the option to create your own All-time Blue Jackets team, who would be on it? Pick a starting goalie, blue liners, and forwards. The only catch, you can't use anyone on the current roster. Use any criteria you want like...career stats, speed, strength, toughness, finesse, fan favoritism, or just make it up. Most importantly, have fun with it.
You can find everyone who has called themselves a Blue Jacket here.