Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Chan Sung Jung Wins Thriller Over Dustin Poirier

Tilting the Ice and......Controversy?


If Time of Possession decided hockey games, this could have been the biggest blowout in Blue Jackets history. The Jackets dominated possession and spent most of the time in the Nashville zone. Since when did Nashville got so docile? They use to check ferociously. Not much fire from them tonight. Especially after the Dumont hit.

The boys wanted it tonight, they wanted it bad. They earned it and got the well needed bubble room in the standings. The two losses shrunk up the cushion. A third would have caused the entire city of Columbus to menstrate. (No offense Lady Jackets)

Here comes the controversy. Prepare Yourself.

I believe there was unmentioned cheating by the Preds in the 3rd. Sullivan had matching minors with Vermette, and Hornqvist got goalie interference giving us the PP. Here's the problem: Sullivan left the box instead of Hornqvist at the expiration of the penalty. Sullivan then was able to carry in the zone and create offense. The officials BLEW this one. CORRECT me if I'm wrong. Good thing it didn't amount to anything. Vermette was stuck in the box for another 2 minutes waiting for a stoppage.

The PK was huge in the 3rd when they needed to be.

The Boll - Peca - Torres line was a very effective line tonight. All of our lines looked great tonight actually, but Peca's was probably the best one. They dominated possession. Raffi "Clutch" Torres has the magic stick. Boll took a bruising slapshot. He's a warrior. We needed the clear and it was a big day.

The reuniting of the Vermette - Umberger - Williams line gave each of the guys a little extra jump. I'm not sure I'd touch that line. They were great when they were together, but were separated to generate more scoring. Irony? Umberger's goal was huge. It would have been depressing to dominate the Preds and go into the locker room down 1-0.

The defense was superb tonight. The puck was moved out of our end swiftly at each opportunity. Nashville did not have much of a forecheck, but that could be a combination of strong puck movement. I'd at least expect a team of youngsters to be tough on the forecheck. It wasn't happening for them tonight.

Russell was amazing. He needs to get a goal.

Mason was great tonight and tacked on another highlight reel save. He made the saves when he needed to make them tonight. He won't make those saves every night, but it needs to be remembered that he can't be expected to make some of those all the time.

Mancrush: 4 high quality lines tonight. All four lines had at least 2 dominating shifts. That is rare. Every line created scoring chances. The pressure was constant. These lines should not be touched for the next game.

Whippin on the officials for that blown call. No way can Sullivan leave the box in that situation. He could have been sprung on a breakaway.

FIRE away at the comments. Let me know if I'm wrong.

Comment 4 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Personally, I believe that they are allowed to do that as they can assign players to take others penalties, right?

http://blogcritics.org/archives/features/abcs_of_columbus_sports.php

by Barga on Mar 31, 2009 10:48 PM EDT reply actions  

Yes you are allowed to have other players serve penalties, but I do not believe that in matching minors and a PP, they are allowed to choose who is released from the box. Perhaps they are since Sullivan's penalty was officially over. It doesn't seem fair that Vermette will have to sit and wait for a whistle and Sullivan can skate, for the same penalty.

I'd love someone to definitively answer this question.

by Clint Clark on Apr 1, 2009 7:00 AM EDT reply actions  

here is my source
so, this is what i discovered:

--"Coincidental minor and/or major penalties result when players of two opposing teams are simultaneously assessed penalties of equal duration. In this case, the players may be substituted for, but all penalized players must serve their full time in the penalty box and wait for a stoppage of play to come out of the box. Generally, the timekeeper will not post these penalties on the scoreboard and the players will be required to stay in the box for the amount of time assessed and until "the next whistle"."--

to me, this means that they are allowed to have Sullivan serve Hornqvst's time and flip the two around, arguably. However, I am not sure that is within the spirit of the rules, nor am I sure that you can substitute other penalty getters for each other; i was unable to find anything about that.

Additionally, under my reading of these rules, they state that coincidal, not offsetting, penalties results in staying in the sin bin, so I would argue that all three needed to stay in

That said, with Hitch knowing the rules front and back, a whole team that is ready to bitch if Nashville pulls something, Vermette sitting right by a dude with a clipboard and rule book, and the announcers, who usually don't have much to do not saying anything, I am sure that some archaic rule allows this

because i am just as curious, I am going to find exactly why this happened, though i now need to see who to email.

http://blogcritics.org/archives/features/abcs_of_columbus_sports.php

by Barga on Apr 1, 2009 8:08 AM EDT reply actions  

I have a hard time buying that is the proper interpretation of the rules, because if so, why don't we just have someone serve all of Rick Nash's penalties so he can always be on the ice?

At the very least, it's unsportsmanlike behavior. At worst, it was an illegal move.

by Andy Newman on Apr 1, 2009 12:30 PM EDT reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about the Columbus Blue Jackets.

FanPosts

29 - 46 - 7

Won 2


Manager

Mikeheadshot_small Mike MacLean

Writers

Andy-newman_small Andy Newman

Headshot_small Matt Wagner

Gog_colum_750px_horiz_beer_small Dan P.

Shhslogo_small Lou Bordeaux